The extension of the existing Wern Cables Sealing End Compound (CSEC) including a new permanent access; a new Minffordd CSEC and Tunnel Head House (THH) with permanent access; the removal of the existing Garth CSEC; installation of new 400 kilovolt (kV) cables to replace redundant 400 kV and 132 kV cables; and other associated infrastructure and ancillary works.
LOCAL MEMBERS:
Councillor Nia Jeffreys
Councillor Gwilym Jones
Councillor June Jones
Councillor Meryl Roberts
Link
to relevant background documents
Decision:
DECISION:
To permit
1. Time Limit
The development must commence within 5 years of the
date of the permission.
2. Approved Schemes
The development to be carried out in accordance with
the approved plans and documents.
3. Hours of Work:
Limits construction work hours and manages
out-of-hours operations.
4. Piling
Requires non-percussive piling methods and restricts
piling hours.
5. Lighting
Requires approval of a lighting scheme to protect bats
and control light spill before operational lighting is installed.
6. Enclosures
Requires
approval of colours and finishes for fences, walls, gates and other boundary
treatments.
7. Contamination
Requires
investigation and remediation of any previously unidentified contamination
encountered during development.
8. Flood Mitigation
Requires approval and implementation of a temporary
flood mitigation scheme for construction works.
9. Wern Registered Park and Garden
Requires a mitigation/offsetting scheme for impacts on
the Wern Registered Park and Garden.
10. Habitat Management and Monitoring Plan (HMP)
Secures habitat compensation, biodiversity net
benefit, habitat monitoring and INNS management over the long term.
11. Landscape and Ecological Management Plan (LEMP)
Secures
landscape restoration, planting, habitat management, ecological monitoring and
long-term maintenance.
12. Archaeological Investigation (WSI)
Requires
archaeological investigation and recording before groundworks commence.
13. Archaeological Reporting
Requires
submission of an archaeological report and archive following fieldwork.
14. Materials and Waste Management Plan
Secures
sustainable management, reuse, recovery and disposal of excavated materials and
waste.
15. Public Rights of Way
Requires management arrangements for public rights of
way and National Cycle Route 8 during construction.
16. Construction Method Statement
Prior to
the commencement of any works on site, Construction Method Statements (CMS) and
Risk Assessments shall be submitted to the satisfaction of the Overseeing
Organisation for the Strategic Roads Network (SRN).
17. Carriageway reinstatement design
Prior to the commencement of any works on site a
carriageway reinstatement design and pavement specification shall be submitted
to the satisfaction of the Welsh Government as Overseeing Organisation for the
Strategic Roads Network.
18. Welsh Water Assets
Requires
surveys and protection/diversion arrangements for water and sewerage
infrastructure.
19. Surface Water Drainage
Prevents connection of surface water to the public
sewer network.
20. Welsh language signs
Requires development-related signage to be Welsh or
bilingual with Welsh given priority.
21. Minffordd Tunnel Head House CTMP
Requires
a package-specific Construction Traffic Management Plan for the Minffordd Tunnel Head House works.
22. Minffordd Tunnel Head House CEMP
Requests a package-specific Construction Environmental
Management Plan for the Minffordd Tunnel Head House
works.
23. Minffordd Tunnel Head House HMP
Requests a package-specific Habitat Management Plan
for the Minffordd Tunnel Head House works.
24. CTMPs for the Main Work Packages
Requires separate Construction Traffic Management
Plans for the Wern CSEC, Garth CSEC, Minffordd CSEC
and Glaslyn Cables work packages.
25. CEMPs for the Main Work Packages
Requires separate Construction Environmental Management
Plans for the Wern CSEC, Garth CSEC, Minffordd CSEC
and Glaslyn Cables work packages.
26. Community facilities restoration plan
Bodawen Playground and Ysgol Eifionydd.
Note: Amendment of Dŵr Cymru/Welsh Water conditions in line with the late
representations received
Minutes:
Extension to the existing Wern cable sealing end compound including a
new permanent access, a new sealing end compound and tunnel head house with
permanent access at Minffordd; removal of the
existing Garth sealing end compound; installation of new 400 kilovolt (kV)
cables to replace redundant 400 kV and 132 kV cables; and related
infrastructure and ancillary works.
Attention was drawn
to the late observations form, specifically a comment from Welsh Water on the
wording of the condition. Reference was made to a correction that comments on
the Railway (paragraph 5.299 - 5.303 of the report), had been submitted by the
Welsh Highland Railway Ltd, which operates the Welsh Highland Heritage Railway.
a)
The Senior Minerals and Waste Planning Officer highlighted that the
Project was a part of the broader network transmission upgrades required to
facilitate the work of connecting 50 Gigawat (GW) of
offshore wind energy by 2030. Increasing capacity on the existing transmission
line between Pentir and Trawsfynydd
substations has been identified as a step that urgently needs to be taken to
provide more transmission capacity. This is acknowledged by Ofgem, the national
energy regulators, who have identified the necessary works as an Accelerated
Strategic Transmission Investment.
The proposed work of the application included encompassing 106.4
hectares and measured approximately 6km between the CSEC (Cable Sealing End
Compounds) of Wern and Minffordd. The path of the
work passes through the Porthmadog Roundabout, under the A487 Porthmadog
Bypass, and crosses the Welsh Highland Heritage Railway (WHHR) and Ffestiniog
and Welsh Highland Railways (FWHR); continuing to the north of Clwb Chwaraeon Madog before
passing again under Porthmadog Bypass. It will cross the Glaslyn Site of
Special Scientific Interest (SSSI) and continue eastwards towards its end point
at the existing Garth CSEC. The proposed work is divided into the following
elements; Wern CSEC, Glaslyn Cables, Garth CSEC, Tunnel Head House and Minffordd CSEC.
It was reported that the application submitted was an Environmental
Impact Assessment application, which has considered all developments that are a
part of the whole Reinforcement Project between Pentir
and Trawsfynydd.
In terms of the principle of the development, it was noted that the new
cables would use XLPE technology, to replace the existing oil-filled cable
system and therefore that there are advantages in terms of modernising the
resilience of the network, as well as reduce the environmental risks associated
with the existing oil cables. It was reiterated that the project was also a
part of the broader network work required to facilitate progress in the
renewable energy provision, therefore the principle is afforded national policy
support, including Future Wales and Planning Policy Wales, which acknowledges
the need for additional grid infrastructure to support the switch to low carbon
energy.
In the context of the landscape and visual amenities, as the cables are
being installed underground, it was considered that the biggest visual impacts
would happen during the construction period. It was explained that the
Landscape and Visual Appraisal identifies temporary moderate and substantial
detrimental impacts in parts of the corridor, including in relation with the
setting of Eryri National Park. To that end, these are local and temporary
impacts with the land, and after installing the cables, will be restored. It
was reiterated that neither Natural Resources Wales (NRW) nor the Eryri
National Park Planning Authority objected to the proposal based on its impact
on the National Park. It was also noted that a condition required a detailed
Landscape and Ecological Management Plan, which will manage the restoration
work, planting, tree preservation and long-term management.
In the context of ecology and biodiversity, which is one of the most
sensitive considerations of the application, it was reported that the path
crosses or ventures close to several sites of ecological importance, most
notably, the Glaslyn SSSI and the Coedydd Derw and Ystlumod Meirion SAC. Around 1.6 hectares of habitat within
the Glaslyn SSSI will be temporarily affected, as well as a limited permanent
loss. It was noted that the design had used Horizontal Drilling, or HDD, in
several of the most sensitive locations in order to
pass under habitats, watercourses and infrastructure, instead of cutting
through them. The Council's Biodiversity Unit raised substantial concerns
regarding restoring habitats, water voles, badgers, tree and hedgerow loss,
lights and the possibility of affecting the flightpath of the lesser horseshoe
bat.
As the work crosses a SAC, the Council conducted a Habitats Regulations
Assessment. The Propriety Assessment
concluded, with relevant mitigation measures, that the proposal will not have a
detrimental impact on the integrity of the relevant SACs. Following the
consultation with NRW on the Propriety Assessment, agreement was reached on the
conclusion, subject to imposing mitigation measures which includes substantial
management via conditions, including managing and monitoring long-term
habitats, LEMP (Landscape and Ecology Management Plan), control of
invasive species, lights and ecological surveys.
When discussing noise and vibration, it was noted that the Environmental
Statement acknowledges that some construction activities can create substantial
noise impacts temporarily, in particular the HDD drilling work in some
locations in Porthmadog and Minffordd with the
possibility that some HDD drilling operations will last for 24 hours for
technical and safety reasons. It was highlighted that the Public Protection
Service has raised concern because not all operational details have been
completed - this includes the exact timing of the noisiest work, mitigation measures
and monitoring arrangements. However, the officers were of the view that these
matters can be managed through a CEMP condition in a specific pack for every
work area, noise and vibration management plans, and,
as appropriate, the process of Section 61 of the Pollution Control Act 1974.
The Planning officers did not disregard the potential impacts; instead, they
recommended that detailed controls are in place before every relevant work pack
commences.
In the context of flooding, it was noted that an extensive proportion of
the work is in an area at flood risk with initial modelling work showing that
the temporary construction infrastructure could increase flood levels in some
areas of Porthmadog and Tremadog. Consequently,
additional hydraulic modelling was conducted, and a temporary mitigation plan
was developed with the strategy, including pumping arrangements to manage the
increase in flood risk during the main construction work. The model was reviewed
by NRW, and they did not object to the development, subject to securing the
mitigation plan by means of a condition. Confirmation was received from the
Lead Local Flood Authority, expressing that they did not have concerns about
the content of the Flood Consequence Assessment. The officers were of the opinion that the proposal could comply with the
requirements of TAN 15.
In terms of traffic matters, an increase in construction traffic would
be expected due to the development, as well as creating temporary new accesses.
Attention was drawn to the Environmental Statement, which projected 148 two-way
vehicular movements per day, including around 100 HGV movements, for the
Glaslyn Cables work. The assessment also notes proportionate increases in HGV
traffic along some roads, but the increase in the total traffic remains
relatively small. Following discussions with the applicant, the North and Mid
Wales Trunk Road Agent confirmed that permission can be granted, subject to
conditions that would ensure traffic management plans, construction method
statements and risk assessments in relation to the Strategic Roads Network. A
condition would also secure detailed control of the Public Rights of Way and
National Cycling Route 8 during the work.
The main elements of heritage can be seen in the Wern area with the
assessment noting the substantial detrimental impact on the Wern Registered
Historic Park and Garden and on the setting of the mansion house. It was
reported that Cadw had raised a substantial concern
about this originally, but following further discussions, they were satisfied
that the impact can be addressed by means of a mitigation or counterbalancing
plan, secured through a planning condition - as a result they no longer
objected to the advice of approving the application. It was reiterated that conditions
secured the archaeological Written Research Plan and subsequent recording work
for the remainder of the development.
In coming to a conclusion, the officer noted
that the plan was major, and noted, obviously there would be substantial
construction impacts, temporary in some locations. All landscape, amenity,
noise and vibration, traffic, flooding, ecology and biodiversity, historical
environment and public rights of way impacts were considered, as well as the
substantial pressures placed on the strategic importance of the electricity
infrastructure, modernising the network, underground nature of a vast part of
the development, temporary nature of many of the impacts, and the proposed
mitigation, restoration and enhancement measures.
Having weighed up all impacts against the strategic need and public
interest, the officers recommended approving the application, subject to
imposing mitigation measures and material planning conditions.
b)
Taking
advantage of the opportunity to speak, a speaker on behalf of the applicant
noted
·
That
the application was a part of the Pentir Trawsfynydd project to reinforce and refurbish the existing
electricity lines.
·
The
proposal will include changing the underground cables between the Wern, Penmorfa and Garth, Minffordd
site.
·
The
work will be a combination of creating open trenches and non-trench techniques
which have been designed so that they cause as little disruption as possible.
·
Work
would be done to extend the existing infrastructure on the Wern site and build
a new cable compound in Minffordd - it will be a link
site for underground and overground cables.
·
The
foundations of the Garth site will be decommissioned.
·
Having
completed the construction work, the temporary work areas will be restored, and
biodiversity will be enhanced in locations off the site in the local area.
·
That
the project will be a part of the upgrade to the national grid - a major
transformation to the UK's electricity network.
·
The
Welsh Government has noted that this is an important plan that will improve the
reliability and security of the electricity supply and supports Wales's
ambition to meet 70% of the renewable source electricity needs by 2030.
·
Planning
Policy Wales acknowledges that an effective electricity network is essential in order to achieve the renewable and low-carbon objectives
of Wales.
·
The
proposal will provide an additional essential electricity transmission capacity
in North Wales, assisting to connect with renewable energy distribution which
is generated now and in the future.
·
That
the proposed development corresponds with local and national policies and the
company has worked with stakeholders to ensure that no key matters remained
unresolved in relation to the application.
·
There
were no objections by statutory stakeholders.
·
The
proposed development is essential infrastructure that will contribute to
achieving the Welsh Government's renewable energy goal.
·
Important
that the connection has been upgraded and operational by 2030 to achieve this
ambition.
c)
Taking
advantage of the right to speak, the local member, Councillor Nia Jeffreys
(Porthmadog East Ward), made the following comments:
·
Thanked
officers for the work.
·
That
she did not object to the application, nevertheless, took the opportunity to
highlight some comments raised by residents in her ward, such as the unique
ecology of Glaslyn, wildlife and birds, the Cob area.
·
That
mitigation measures need to be secured during the construction period to reduce
the impact on local people - issues such as traffic, travel, noise and dust.
·
That Bodawen
Playing Field was very important to the children of Porthmadog and Tremadog and so sought assurances that the playing field
would be reopened as soon as possible after the work was completed - the same
was the request regarding the Ysgol Eifionydd playing
fields - a request not to close the fields for too long.
In response to the
comments regarding the playing fields, the Officer referred to the agreement
reached with Porthmadog Town Council that everything would be reinstated after
the completion period, but that it would be possible to impose an additional, more
detailed condition, to secure control over the re-installation of the
equipment.
Taking advantage of the
right to speak, the local member, Councillor Gwilym Jones (Porthmadog West
Ward), made the following comments:
·
That
he agreed with the comments of Cllr Nia Jeffreys, particularly the comment on Cae Bodawen as discussions had
been held with the Town Council and the National Grid.
·
That
assurances were needed that the old cables did not contain polychlorinated
biphenyl compound, which is material that was used in electrical equipment in
the 1970s - although he had discussed this and had obtained assurances that
forever chemicals, as they were commonly referred to, were not in
the old cables, no reference to this matter could be seen in the report.
ch) It was proposed and seconded to approve the
application in accordance with the recommendation.
d)
During the ensuing discussion, the following
observations were made by members:
·
Why
was Pentir to Trawsfynydd
the priority, considering that other areas of the County needed a better
connection?
·
That
the plan appeared to be rushed and despite acknowledging the substantial risks
such as traffic, noise and dust, the community risks had not been considered.
·
More
information was needed on how to mitigate the risks to ensure that the process
was less obtrusive to the local community and to nature and ecology in the
areas.
·
That
the Biodiversity Unit had noted insufficient mitigation measures in terms of
details regarding the long-term period, suggesting that the situation should be
monitored for 25 years, not 5 years. Could the biodiversity conditions be
strengthened before it is approved?
·
That
the scheme ran through a very sensitive area - consistency and fairness was
needed when interpreting what a 'sensitive area' was in planning applications.
·
That
the need had been noted clearly; a bulk of work had been done on the
application with several recommendations and conditions to manage it.
·
Welcomed
the fact that this was an application to underground and not install pylons.
·
The
national grid, in its current form, was not fit-for-purpose when looking
towards the future.
·
This
was an opportunity to take advantage of green energy.
In response to a
comment that the application seemed to be rushed, the officer noted that the
application submitted was one that had been prioritised by Ofgem to improve the
network between Pentir and Trawsfynydd
to facilitate the work of connecting 50 Gigawat (GW)
of offshore wind energy by 2030. The Assistant Head of Department reiterated
that the application had not been rushed and that it would not have been
submitted to the Committee unless it was ready. It was noted that a detailed
assessment of every material planning consideration had been thoroughly
considered and after weighing-up all material planning
considerations, the Planning Authority was of the view that the development was
acceptable with further mitigation measures associated to the conditions. He
reiterated that the application to upgrade the electricity network was not
unique to Gwynedd - that developments were happening across Britain; the
application was supported in terms of principle by Welsh Government policies
and local policies.
RESOLVED: To approve with conditions
1. Time Limit
The development must commence within
5 years of the date of the permission.
2. Approved Plans
The development to be carried out in
accordance with the approved plans and documents.
3. Hours of Work
Limits construction work hours and
manages out-of-hours operations.
4. Piling
Requires non-percussive piling
methods and restricts piling hours.
5. Lighting
Requires approval of a lighting
scheme to protect bats and control light spill before operational lighting is
installed.
6. Enclosures
Requires approval of colours and
finishes for fences, walls, gates and other boundary treatments.
7. Contamination
Requires investigation and
remediation of any previously unidentified contamination encountered during
development.
8. Flood Mitigation
Requires approval and implementation
of a temporary flood mitigation scheme for construction works.
9. Wern Registered Park and Garden
Requires a mitigation/offsetting
scheme for impacts on the Wern Registered Park and Garden.
10. Habitat Management and Monitoring Plan
(HMP)
Secures habitat compensation,
biodiversity net benefit, habitat monitoring and INNS management over the long
term.
11. Landscape and Ecological Management Plan
(LEMP)
Secures landscape restoration,
planting, habitat management, ecological monitoring and long-term
maintenance.
12. Archaeological Investigation (WSI)
Requires archaeological investigation
and recording before groundworks commence.
13. Archaeological Reporting
Requires submission of an
archaeological report and archive following fieldwork.
14. Materials and Waste Management Plan
Secures sustainable management,
reuse, recovery and disposal of excavated materials and waste.
15. Public Rights of Way
Requires management arrangements for
public rights of way and National Cycle Route 8 during construction.
16. Construction Method Statement
Prior to the commencement of any
works on site, Construction Method Statements (CMS) and Risk Assessments shall
be submitted to the satisfaction of the Overseeing Organisation for the
Strategic Roads Network (SRN).
17. Carriageway reinstatement design
Prior to the commencement of any
works on site a carriageway reinstatement design and pavement specification
shall be submitted to the satisfaction of the Welsh Government as Overseeing
Organisation for the Strategic Roads Network.
18. Welsh Water Assets
Requires surveys and protection/diversion
arrangements for water and sewerage infrastructure.
19. Surface Water Drainage
Prevents
connection of surface water to the public sewer network.
20. Welsh language signs
Requires development-related signage
to be Welsh or bilingual with Welsh given priority.
21. Minffordd Tunnel Head House
Requires a package-specific
Construction Traffic Management Plan for the Minffordd
Tunnel Head House works.
22. Minffordd Tunnel Head House CEMP
Requests a package-specific Construction
Environmental Management Plan for the Minffordd
Tunnel Head House works.
23. Minffordd Tunnel Head House HMP
Requests a package-specific Habitat
Management Plan for the Minffordd Tunnel Head House
works.
24. CTMPs for the Main Work Packages
Requires separate Construction
Traffic Management Plans for the Wern CSEC, Garth CSEC, Minffordd
CSEC and Glaslyn Cables work packages.
25. CEMPs for the Main Work Packages
Requires separate Construction Environmental
Management Plans for the Wern CSEC, Garth CSEC, Minffordd
CSEC and Glaslyn Cables work packages.
26. Community facilities restoration plan
Bodawen and Ysgol Eifionydd
Playing Fields.
Note: Amendment of Dŵr
Cymru Welsh Water conditions in line with the late representations received
Supporting documents: