To
scrutinise the Climate and Nature Emergency Plan Annual Report 2025/26.
Decision:
1.
To
accept the report, noting the observations made during the discussion.
2.
To
welcome the intention to discuss with Welsh Government Ministers the
methodology of calculating carbon emissions in the area of Procurement, along
with a successor to the EC04 scheme which is ending.
Minutes:
The report was
presented by the Climate Change Programme Manager stating that it reported on
work undertaken in 2025/26 and under the original Climate and Nature Emergency
plan, which had now been updated and adopted by the Cabinet in summer 2026.
It was expressed
that the Council had been reporting on Carbon emissions to the Welsh Government
for four years now. It was explained that this provided a firm foundation to
see whether progress was going in the right direction. It was also noted that figures
were presented 'including procurement' and 'excluding procurement' measures, as
the methodology was not entirely accurate with procurement as it was
expenditure-based. It was explained that both pictures showed that they were on
the right track. It was detailed that carbon emissions were falling and carbon
absorption levels had remained unchanged because they had used 2024/25
statistics, but the gap was closing. It was added that there were explanations for
this in the report, but they included a work investment on reducing emissions
from buildings' energy use, the installation of fleet charging points and that
the waste strategy was now operational. It was emphasised that the picture was
broad and complex but that they were on the right track.
During the discussion, the following observations were
made:
Members thanked the officer for the
report and attention was drawn to calculating carbon emissions from the
procurement system, noting that if it was solely expenditure-based then how
could net zero be reached. With rising costs, it would not be achievable as it
was a constantly moving target. It was added that with increased fuel costs,
emissions would rise through this measure. It was noted that it was absurd to
count carbon footprint through procurement as no one could reach net zero. He
stressed that he was aware that this was a Welsh Government measure but it did
not reflect the situation and that it really needed to be questioned. The
response was that they fully agreed with the observations but that the Council
had taken one positive step by looking at procurement processes. It was
explained that a lot of time had been spent supporting suppliers and helping
them to develop their own carbon management plans. In doing so, it was
explained that it had led to a reduction in carbon levels within the companies
and enabled them to provide accurate carbon data which was fed back to the
Welsh Government. They elaborated by noting that a higher percentage of the
data was accurate as a result of the support provided, but if we wanted to see
this type of project across Wales then much more resources would be needed. It
was added that the Cabinet Member had asked the new Government for a further
discussion on this measure.
Attention was drawn to the Carbon
Absorption chart by the Council's land assets, and it was asked why there had
been a large reduction in the first two years of the plan followed by a gradual
increase, with 2025/26 numbers higher than they were in 2021/22. The response
given was that the methodology used in the first two years differed to that
used in the subsequent three years. It was noted that, to obtain the full
picture, the context to accompany the chart was needed. It was added that there
had been little change in land use and therefore that 2024/25 data had been
used for this year and that discussions were underway between the Welsh
Government and the Welsh Local Government Association (WLGA) to find the right
approach to measuring carbon absorption levels.
It was expressed that the gap to net
zero was still high after it had initially fallen in 2020/21. They responded by
noting that the gap had narrowed since the baseline year in 2019, but that it
came back to the fact that carbon absorption levels by land assets was much
lower in 2020/21 compared to the subsequent year. It was expressed that there
would be an improvement this year, but this could be confirmed when there were
new measurement arrangements for measuring the absorption level.
The staff who worked so hard in this
area were thanked, and it was noted that miraculous work was being done with so
little budget. It was emphasised that these schemes were savings hundreds of
thousands of pounds for the Council which helped with the savings that the
Council needed to make every year. It was highlighted that the ECO4 initiative
was coming to an end this year, which involved working with the Government to
help Gwynedd residents to reduce energy costs. It was asked what would happen
next, and if there was room for the Scrutiny Committee to support the Cabinet
Member to query the Government about the next steps in relation to the ECO4
initiative. The response given was that there would be a discussion about
procurement with the Government and that the ECO4 initiative could be brought
up as part of that discussion.
It was asked what projects completed
in 2025/26 had had a measurable impact on reducing the gap to net zero, and
which projects had not reduced emissions and how much of the progress was as a
result of grants rather than sustainable changes to reduce expenditure from the
core budget. The response was that several building and energy schemes had
received many grants and that some would result in financial savings due to the
reduction in energy costs. In terms of saving money, it was expressed that some
schemes had reached neutrality where there was no increase or decrease.
It was pointed out that the gap to
net zero excluding procurement remained at 16,937,946 kgCO2e at the rate, and
it was asked how many years it would take to reach net zero and why there was a
need to keep to the 2030 target which continued to look unrealistic. It was
added that the carbon absorption level had remained stagnant, and it was asked
whether it therefore indicated that the ecological strategy had failed so far
or whether there was a wider explanation. It was expressed how Cyngor Gwynedd's
carbon emissions contributed at all to global climate change when they were so
small, when several countries were now abandoning the Paris Agreement as a
result of scientific evidence highlighting a negative impact on the economy.
The response given was that the latest Climate and Nature Emergency Plan
adopted by the Cabinet in July provided more information in relation to the
2030 target, emphasising that it was challenging. It was noted that this had
been reinforced by the Welsh Government who had mentioned that it was a target
to be met in 2040. It was emphasised that this was currently an active
discussion between a number of organisations.
It was asked what the real estimated
cost was to close the gap by 2030 and where would the money come from if grants
stopped – would the Council be prepared to change the target or what services
would suffer due to the focus and expenditure on this plan. It was elaborated
that grant funding came from the taxpayer's pocket and therefore needed to be
spent carefully. The response was that there was nothing free in the society we
lived in, but the Council needed to make the most of the grants that were being
offered. It was noted that the Council had a Carbon plan back in 2005 and it
was therefore part of the Council's culture to continue with the work as it
saved money for the Council and the taxpayer and ensured that services were
delivered as effectively as possible.
1. To accept the report, noting the observations made
during the discussion.
2. To welcome the intention to discuss with Welsh Government
Ministers the methodology of calculating carbon emissions in the area of
Procurement, along with a successor to the EC04 scheme which is ending.
Supporting documents: