To review
current arrangements.
Decision:
1.
To
accept the report, noting the observations made during the discussion.
2.
To
declare support for developing a business plan for investment to enable the
service to undertake a high percentage of road-marking work internally.
3.
To
recommend to the Highways, Engineering and YGC Department that a performance
measure should be developed with regard to
prioritising road marking and the safety of all road users, including
pedestrians and cyclists.
Minutes:
The report was
presented, stating that the department was currently looking at steps to
improve the service. The current working arrangements were noted which involved
an external contractor carrying out road marking works, except for a single
manual road marking machine in the south of the county. It was emphasised that
there were only two contractors working across North Wales, so the waiting time
to get the works done could be long. Attention was drawn to the steps to improve
the service, as set out in the report. It was noted that step two was to invest
in an additional manual road marking machine, along with training staff to use
it, for use in the north of the county.
It was explained
that step 3 involved developing a business plan to invest in a bespoke road
marking vehicle, submitting an invest-to-save bid. It was added that this would
ensure that works were done faster and that there would be an opportunity to offer
work to neighbouring counties and generate income. It was added that operating
it internally would make it much easier to manage the situation.
During the
discussion, the following observations were made:
It was noted that the fact that there were
only two contractors available to carry out the work, highlighted the need to
support this case. However, it was expressed that it would be useful to see the
financial case for that as well, perhaps when presenting to the Cabinet to see
the picture over 5-10 years in terms of staffing and maintenance costs along
with the additional income. The response given was that these figures were
essential to submit the bid, but this stage had not been reached yet. It was
noted that the cost would be around £200k investment-wise to purchase the
machine. It was explained that initial talks had begun with the Trunk Roads
Agency, which had noted support and work if going down the investment avenue.
It was elaborated that there had been an initial discussion with nearby
counties. It was expressed that it was not only the financial element that was
crucial but also the Council's reputation, of providing a timely and rapid
response. It was noted that an investment had been made for step 2, which was a
step in the right direction.
It was asked how the success of the
service could be defined, as road markings were important for traffic and
safety whilst also being necessary for pedestrians and cyclists. It was asked
how the system considered different users when prioritising road markings, and
how performance measures allowed us to see the scale and location of works, and
what needs were being met. The response given was that prioritisation came down
to risk assessment and that road safety was part of the road inspector's job,
taking into account the entire road including the road markings. It was
explained that measures came into the performance challenge system and that
examples would be considered when reporting.
Attention was drawn to road markings
following re-surfacing works. It was explained that a period of 6 or more weeks
sometimes lapsed before they were replaced which was concerning as accidents
could happen and that safety problems could arise in front of schools. It was
asked whether there was a period of time where it was not possible to install
road markings after re-surfacing works. The response given was that they were
aware of the risks when there were delays and specifically for those unfamiliar
with the area. It was explained that remarking lines was part of contractors'
agreement when carrying out resurfacing works which tended to happen quite
close to the end of the period. However, it was emphasised that only two
contractors had the machinery to paint road markings for large spaces – for
example centre line road marking works. As a result, the Council was at the
mercy of the contractor and often had to get a large package of work for them
to come to the county. In terms of marking in front of schools, it was
explained that it scored high in terms of prioritisation and that the
department was able to use the manual machine to do the work in-house.
Gratitude was noted for the work done,
highlighting that they had been very proactive in his ward. The steps to
improve the service were supported and it was asked what was now being used to
install the road markings, as there had been a change to use more
environmentally friendly material. It was asked whether it was hard-wearing.
The response was that the department had been using material that was not as
high-spec compared to what was available on the open market. It was added that
locations had been identified where a lot of wear and tear occurred in order to
trial very durable material to compare the lifespan of the markings.
Support was declared for the investment,
and it was highlighted that there was pioneering machinery coming from China,
and it was asked if there was any intention to invest in smaller machinery. The
response was that they were investing in a second manual kit to be based in the
north of the county, and that step 3 was for a larger vehicle.
It was expressed that the current
arrangements were not working and that more work needed to be done in-house. A
question was asked about the external contractors, whether the Council paid
them to stay overnight, and in terms of the business plan regarding whether it
would be necessary to invest in more staff. The response given was that the
Business Plan would highlight the need for an additional workforce as it would
be unavoidable. It was explained that the Council did not pay contractors to
stay overnight which could be challenging as travel time needed to be scheduled
in as well.
When discussing the road markings, more
than one member asked if the lines were applied with paint or by burning and if
different machines were needed for the different colours. It was explained that
hot application of markings was used and that the same procedure was used for
the manual equipment in the south of the county. It was explained that both
colours were on the same vehicle and worked independently of each other.
It was asked if another authority was
thinking of going down the same path and investing. The response was that
discussions had taken place and there was no intention of doing this but
obviously the situation could change over time.
It was expressed that the department was
fortunate to have taken steps to try to resolve the problem. But it was asked
what they would do if the business bid was unsuccessful. The response was that
they had already invested in step two which would make some improvement, but
that step 3 was specifically for the large schemes where the Council was
required to use external contractors. As a result, without any investment, the
situation would continue as it was.
RESOLVED
1. To accept
the report, noting the observations made during the discussion.
2. To declare
support for developing a business plan for investment to enable the service to
undertake a high percentage of road-marking work internally.
3. To recommend
to the Highways, Engineering and YGC Department that a performance measure should
be developed with regard to prioritising road marking and the safety of all
road users, including pedestrians and cyclists.
Supporting documents: