Ensure that
appropriate arrangements are in place for the management and co-ordination of
road closures in urgent and emergency circumstances.
Decision:
1.
To
accept the report, noting the observations made during the discussion.
2.
To
ask the Environment Department to share data including the number of road
closures in urgent or emergency circumstances, the distribution across areas,
and works that take longer than expected.
Minutes:
The report was
presented, stating that emergency road closures were one part of the work of
the Street Works unit on county roads. It was expressed that in accordance with
the legislation, they were responsible for enabling statutory undertakers to
carry out works on the roads. It was added that there were different processes
to follow when emergency works arose compared to scheduled works. It was noted
that, in an emergency, engagement was not possible as they could not predict where
and when they would happen across such a wide county network. It was explained
that the unit coordinated work in the area, but aimed to minimise disruption to
communities while bearing in mind the need for urgent or emergency works to be
carried out by statutory contractors. It was expressed that, in an age of
communication, it was easy to get information out in an emergency which could
be helpful but also work against them when a high amount of information was
shared or if the time period was short which could create confusion that was
difficult to retract.
During the
discussion, the following observations were made:
Specific issues with road closures in one
area were highlighted, citing a lack of communication between the Council and
those carrying out the work. It was explained that the Councillor had contacted
the Council on many occasions to note that the road was closed as the Council
was not aware of the work, particularly by Dŵr Cymru/Welsh Water. It was
asked if better cooperation with the road closure companies was possible. It
was explained that Dŵr Cymru had commissioned a company from Cheshire to
close roads, but the works had not taken place and the residents had consequently
reopened the road themselves. It was added that the road had been closed
following this unbeknownst to anyone, therefore this had led to public
transport problems.
The response given was that they fully
sympathised with and understood the frustration and that they aimed to have a
healthy relationship with the statutory contractors and that it was expected of
them to share information. While he did not have specific details about the
case in question, it was expressed that cases could change following an
inspection and seeing the extent of the work. It was noted that the system was
not perfect but that they were keen to work together to improve it. It was
stressed that it was essential to receive examples, and that they had regular
meetings with the undertakers to see improvement. It was noted that Dŵr
Cymru had experienced difficulties following appointing a new traffic
management company but they had now seen an improvement. It was added that they
fined if a road was closed without warning.
When asked about traffic arrangements, it
was asked who sent the maps for traffic diversions. It was noted that these
were very useful to share with residents. An example of a diversion following a
road closure by Dŵr Cymru was highlighted which went much further than
what residents regarded as being necessary as there were several junctions. The
response was that if a road had to be closed then the diversion had to be on a
similar class road or higher to ensure that they could accommodate heavy
vehicles such as buses. It was explained that when work needed to be done, it
was essential in order to maintain services and that there were protocols to
follow – as a result, some diversions could be extended depending on where the
road closure was. It was added that the alternative plans were presented by the
statutory undertakers, but the Council had a role to challenge and to use local
knowledge to adapt them where necessary in accordance with the act.
Another example was highlighted where
Dŵr Cymru had closed the road due to a burst pipe on a hill. A notice had
been received that the works would be carried out in 3 weeks which meant
surface water for 5 weeks. The Councillor had contacted the Council, and the
works were carried out within 24 hours. Using this example, officers were asked
if they could assess the need for works before sharing the notice as it might
be escalated to an emergency. The response was that the status of the works
could change over time. It was explained that the service had three officers
across the county to inspect work and to see if works had been completed to a
high standard. It was stressed that the number of road closure requests was
high and in addition to the duties of these officers, so the work was very
wide-ranging.
Members expressed their understanding that
the law had to be followed but a road closure on a single access corridor was
pointed out, and it was noted that there was a need to assess the risk of the
impact on communities and balance whether the work really needed to be done. A
specific instance was highlighted which was not an emergency but urgent works,
and the diversion had been over 40 miles with a major impact on several
communities. It was noted that the report set out next steps that were vague
and there were no measurable targets to ensure that this did not happen again.
The response was that no one wanted this to happen, but the service was trying
its best and it could prove challenging when emergency works arose out of hours
without the extent of the works being known. The need to keep in touch with the
Council to obtain accurate information from the official channels was
emphasised, but it was noted that the line of communication could be long. It
was noted that officers would arrange to visit the Councillor to discuss the
problems in her area and to highlight the work being done to alleviate
problems.
It was noted that some roads required
different protocols, which had a major impact on communities such as a single
access corridor road, to fully understand the impact. It was enquired if there
could be one contact person for emergencies. It was noted that the number of
officers was low but the office could be contacted, and they would share a
dedicated direct number and officer.
It was highlighted
that one statutory undertaker had been highlighted during this meeting, namely
Dŵr Cymru, and it was noted that this may need to be relayed to them.
It was asked whether more data could be
obtained in terms of how many road closures happened, how many were emergency
or urgent works, how many took more time than scheduled, and where the works
were in terms of their distribution. It was also asked if there was a
discussion about works arising in the same place with the same provider
repeatedly. The response given was that this data could be provided following
the committee as some elements were part of the Performance Challenge system.
It was noted that the report had several
references to continuous improvement and a request was made for examples and
how the service had changed. The response was that many of the improvements
were in team dynamics in terms of experiences and were not documented. But a
clear element was communication, the need and desire to inform everyone in a
timely manner, and to keep in touch with Councillors.
It was asked who
was responsible for informing the emergency services of road closures. It was responded that the
Council took the role of informing the emergency services, Councillors and
Community Council of road closures.
RESOLVED
1. To accept
the report, noting the observations made during the discussion.
2.
To ask the Environment Department to share data
including the number of road closures in urgent or emergency circumstances, the
distribution across areas, and works that take longer than expected.
Supporting documents: