Venue: Hybrid - Siambr Dafydd Orwig, Swyddfeydd y Cyngor, Caernarfon LL55 1SH
Contact: Annes Sion 01286 679490
| No. | Item |
|---|---|
|
APOLOGIES To receive any apologies for absence. Additional documents: Minutes: Apologies
were received from Councillors Gareth A Roberts, Menna Baines, Dafydd Meurig
and Gareth Coj Parry. |
|
|
The Chair shall propose that the minutes of the
previous meeting of the Council held on 14 May 2026 be signed as a true record. Additional documents: Minutes: |
|
|
DECLARATION OF PERSONAL INTEREST To receive any declarations of personal interest. Additional documents: Minutes: There were no declarations of personal interest. |
|
|
THE CHAIRMAN'S ANNOUNCEMENTS To receive any Chair’s announcements. Additional documents: Minutes: Condolences
were noted with the family of Robin Evans from Caernarfon, originally from
Eifionydd, who had recently passed away. He made a significant contribution to
the television industry, being one of the founders of Ffilmiau'r Nant and Rondo
here in Gwynedd, as well as an original member of the band Mynediad am Ddim.
Condolences were extended to families in Gwynedd who had recently lost loved
ones. Councillor
Dawn Lynne Jones was congratulated on winning the Police Commissioner's
Community award. Congratulations were expressed to Lois Medi from Bangor for
winning the Chair at the Urdd Eisteddfod, Dafydd Llŷr Hughes from
Llanbedrog on winning the Urdd Eisteddfod's Young Artist Scholarship and Katie
Baddiley who is a Police Community Support Officer in Dyffryn Nantlle for
winning the Bobi Jones Medal. All the children and young people of the county
who competed and were successful in the Eisteddfod were also congratulated. Congratulations
were noted to Leisa Gwenllian and the entire cast and production team of the
film ‘Effi o Blaenau’. Good luck wishes were given to all the athletes in the
county who would be representing Wales at the Commonwealth Games this summer. |
|
|
URGENT ITEMS To note any items which
are urgent business in the opinion of the Chair so they may
be considered. Additional documents: Minutes: None to note. |
|
|
To consider
any questions the appropriate notice for which have
been given under Section 4.18 of the Constitution. Additional documents: Minutes: (The Cabinet Members'
written responses to the questions had been published in advance.) (1)
Question by Councillor Huw Rowlands Is the
Cabinet Member for Adults, Health and Well-being aware of the growing public
frustration at the significant delay by Betsi Cadwaladr Health Board and Grŵp
Cynefin in establishing a health centre in Penygroes, namely Canolfan Lleu, and
also the significant delay by Betsi Cadwaladr Health Board in establishing a
new Health Centre in Waunfawr? Answer from
Cabinet Member for Adults, Health and Well-being, Councillor Dilwyn Morgan The
Councillor was thanked for the question and the opportunity to raise awareness
about issues affecting the public. As a result of the important messages
contained in the written response, he stated that he would read it as follows. In my role
as Chair of the North Wales Regional Partnership Board, I work closely with the
Health Board and receive regular reports on the situation. These reports are relevant
to the plans identified but also to wider plans to improve health provision
across the region. I therefore confirm that I am aware of the situation and
understand the frustrations. However, I
would like to offer reassurance to the member of the positive work and strong
collaboration that is taking place between our social and health services in
Dyffryn Nantlle and Waunfawr. Professionals from both organisations hold
regular meetings, joint visits, collaborative assessments and multidisciplinary
discussions to ensure that individuals receive the right support at the right
time. A strong culture of collaborative problem-solving has developed, and this
is true across the county – not just for the areas involved, with staff working
creatively and flexibly to find practical solutions to complex needs. There are
good examples of collaboration between health and social care teams to prevent
unnecessary hospital admissions, facilitate timely discharge when individuals are
ready to leave hospital, and ensure that appropriate support is in place in the
community. Close collaboration is also taking place with Tuag Adref services to
ensure a proportionate and seamless continuity of care for individuals during
the transition from hospital back to their homes and communities. These
arrangements are proof of the collaboration between local partners with the aim
of improving outcomes for local people and to provide more integrated and
effective services. Supplementary
Question by Councillor Huw Rowlands What can
Cyngor Gwynedd do to ensure the realisation of Canolfan Iechyd Waunfawr and
Canolfan Lleu in the foreseeable future? Answer
from Cabinet Member for Adults, Health and Well-being, Councillor Dilwyn Morgan
The
Councillor was thanked for the question. Upon receiving the original question,
he stated that he had contacted the Chair of the Health Board in person and had
now received from him a full timetable of what the plans were at both locations.
He noted that he would share this with the Member who had asked the question
along with the local members for those areas. (2)
Question by Councillor Gruffydd
Williams Following the Supreme Court's unanimous ruling in the case of For Women Scotland v ... view the full minutes text for item 6. |
|
|
ANNUAL REPORT OF THE STANDARDS COMMITTEE 2025/26 To submit the report of the Chair of the Standards Committee. Additional documents: Decision: To
accept the report. Minutes: The Chair of the Standards
Committee presented the Committee's Annual Report. The Chair noted that it had
been a quiet year with not a single hearing held. Members were thanked for
their work in upholding the Council's high standards and for their support to
the Town and Community Councils when the need arose. The Monitoring Officer and
his team were thanked for their support and also the Group Leaders for
prioritising the matter. Members
were given the opportunity to ask questions and make observations. A question was asked about
the complaints’ framework and the timescale. A response was given which assumed
that the question was about complaints to the Ombudsman as the Standards
Committee did not receive complaints. It was explained that, in regard to the
Standards Committee, if a complaint was received by the Ombudsman that it would
be dealt with in a matter of weeks. Looking at the Ombudsman, it was expressed
that the timescale could be up to a year for a full inquiry. It was RESOLVED to accept the report. |
|
|
ANNUAL REPORT OF THE GOVERNANCE AND AUDIT COMMITTEE To submit the report
of the Chair of the Governance
and Audit Committee. Additional documents:
Decision: To
accept the report. Minutes: The report
was presented by the Chair of the Governance and Audit Committee during
2025/26. It was expressed that this was the fourth time that the report had
been presented in line with the Welsh Government's expectations and guidance.
It was explained that the report provided a summary of the Committee's work
along with evidence of its impact. It was
noted that all Local Authorities were facing a number of challenges and there
were ongoing pressures on statutory service budgets particularly in care. It
was explained that she believed that the Council's governance arrangements had
continued to show resilience. In the face of these financial challenges, it was
reiterated that the Committee's role in terms of financial scrutiny had been
central and had played a prominent role in scrutinising the budget, monitoring
overspending and assessing risks to the Council's financial sustainability in
the medium and long term. All
officers, Elected Members and Lay Members were thanked for their commitment and
contribution throughout the year. It was added that 2025/26 had been a year of
strengthening and stabilising the membership of the Committee. It was expressed
that the year had followed a period of significant loss with the deaths of the
late Sharon Warnes and Councillor Rob Triggs, but that their contribution to
the work of the Committee and their dedication to public service continued to
inspire them to continue with the work. Members were given an opportunity to ask questions and make observations.
It was
pointed out that CIPFA guidelines emphasised the need to demonstrate the impact
of the work, and it was asked whether this element could be strengthened by
perhaps showing clearer examples of changes as a result of the committee. More
information was requested about the two members of staff who recently had press
coverage for being on full pay for a period of over 9 years while
investigations were ongoing. It was asked on what pay scale they were and if
there were more people on full pay over a long period of time while
investigations were ongoing. The response given was that individual staff could
not be discussed in an open meeting, but that they understood the Councillor's
frustration but was not relevant to this report. It was added that a review was
underway and that conclusions would be drawn in due course. It was RESOLVED
to accept the report. |
|
|
SOCIAL SERVICES ANNUAL REPORT 2025/26 To submit the report of the Statutory Director of Social Services. Additional documents: Decision: To accept
the report. Minutes: The report
was presented by the Corporate Director for Social Services. To start
his presentation, a video was shown about the electronic cats being offered to
help people experiencing loneliness and isolation. The report was presented by firstly thanking the staff that the Director
had to assist him with the work. It was expressed that the video shown was one
of many that promoted and explained the work that Social Services did, and
celebrated the good work being done. However, it was noted that it was
difficult to stand there and boast after such a turbulent year. The
importance of the Our Bravery Brought Justice report was highlighted despite
how difficult it was to acknowledge what had happened along with the long-term
implications for the Council and Social Services. Pride was expressed in the
positive and constructive work that had been done to ensure that the Council's
safeguarding and protection arrangements were optimised. It was noted that it
was a tragedy for the individuals along with the staff and pupils of Ysgol
Friars who had been affected. Further details were given on the safeguarding
work that had been done which extended beyond Social Services and that work was
being done in conjunction with Corporate Services to highlight that it was
everyone's responsibility. It was added that a website highlighting the steps
to report any concerns, support and information would be launched soon. It was
noted that the department was incredibly big in size with expenditure of almost
£150 million, with 1500 in-house staff and almost 3000 staff when looking at
commissioned work. As a result, it was reiterated that the size and vastness of
the services made it challenging for Councillors to challenge the services on
their work. It was emphasised that failures were inevitable and that they had
been very evident through the Our Bravery Brought Justice report and more
recently the Bryn Ffynnon case, despite the department's efforts to improve
services. It was explained that it was a significantly important system but one
that was under pressure and that children and adults needed to be better protected
and safeguarded, and that they were under pressure to improve which required an
investment. It was highlighted that a lot of money had been invested over the
last few months to be able to respond to challenges sooner. It was emphasised that money was a challenge. It was explained that internal money was being spent transparently but that external costs such as the costs of specialist children's homes were extremely high and that the demand for services was increasing. It was highlighted that children's referrals had almost doubled since Covid with almost 8,000 cases over the past year. It was highlighted that the work of Llechen Lân had been published which highlighted that the demography of Gwynedd was challenging with fewer young people and more older people, resulting in a challenge of delivering services for the future. It was elaborated that the report provided some answers but also called on the ... view the full minutes text for item 9. |
|
|
ANNUAL REPORT OF THE HEAD OF DEMOCRACY SERVICES 2025/26 To submit the report of the Head of Democracy Services. Additional documents: Decision: To accept
the report. Minutes: The report
by the Head of Democracy Services was presented stating that it was a
requirement to present a report outlining the work undertaken over the past
year. The Former Chair was thanked for her work, and congratulations were noted
to Cllr. Dewi Owen for being elected as Chair. Thanks were expressed to the
Democracy Service Committee for their input and to the team for their
professionalism throughout the year. Attention
was drawn to the highlights of the year with reference to the start of
preparations for the 2027 Election along with plans to improve the digital
provision in the Chambers. Attention was drawn to the eighth core area added to
the members' training area and members were asked to complete the available
training. This year's priorities were noted which followed on from last year's
work with the forthcoming Election. Members
were given an opportunity to ask questions and make observations. Attention
was drawn to the core training areas highlighting that numbers reported to have
completed training were still low and emphasising figures such as 3 members not
having completed any of the eight areas. The importance of the training and the
fact that it was available on-line at any time was highlighted. It was
asked if there was a discussion about councillors facing a by-election if
changing political group during a democratic term. The response was that there
were no steps at a Local Government level to impose such a requirement. It was
asked where the information was available about members' training. It was
explained that it was public information on the website and available on the
Members' Self-Service, but Councillors were asked to get in touch if they
needed assistance. Thanks were
noted for all the training available which was very beneficial. Cara, the
former Members' Training Officer, was thanked for her work over the years. It was RESOLVED to accept the report. |
|
|
CYNGOR GWYNEDD'S STATEMENT REGARDING PROMOTING DIVERSITY To submit the Cyngor
Gwynedd Diversity Statement, together with the Work Programme. Additional documents:
Decision: To adopt
the updated Diversity in Democracy Statement with the associated work programme
to support the statement. Minutes: The report
was presented by the Cabinet Member for Corporate Services noting that the
Council had adopted a Diversity Statement back in October 2021 in line with the
Local Government Act 2021. It was explained that the statement highlighted the
Council's commitment to encouraging and promoting greater diversity ahead of
the 2027 Local Government election. With the
forthcoming Local Election, it was noted that it was timely to review the
statement. It was highlighted that it was not a statutory requirement but that
it was believed that Members were keen to ensure a fair representation of
society, and to encourage individuals from all backgrounds to stand as a
Councillor. It was
noted that there had been no significant change to the statement since 2021,
only a few updates. Attention was drawn to the work programme which would
accompany the statement which highlighted the steps that would be taken by the
Democracy Team and the Elections Team. It was highlighted that the statement had been supported by the Democracy
Services Committee at their meeting a fortnight ago. Members were given the opportunity to ask questions and make
observations. Thanks were
noted for the report, and the statement of having Councillors who reflect the
communities served and to remove barriers that ensure people of all backgrounds
and ages are involved in local politics was welcomed. Support was
expressed highlighting that it was easy to say that more diversity was needed
but that the Political Groups had a role to play in promoting and encouraging
this diversity. It was noted that a single transferrable voting system would
make it easier. The response given was that working with the Political Groups was
part of the work programme, and that it was through Plaid Cymru's encouragement
to get more young women into politics that the Cabinet Member had become a
Councillor. It was
asked what barriers had been identified as the main ones that prevented people
from standing. A conversation beyond the meeting with the member was welcomed
to give fair consideration to the matter. It was
RESOLVED to adopt the revised Diversity in Democracy Declaration along with the
work programme to support the declaration. |
|
|
MEMBERS CONFIDENTIAL REPORTING POLICY ("WHISTLEBLOWING") To submit the report
of the Cabinet Member for
Corporate Services, Legal and Welsh Language Additional documents:
Decision: The Members
Confidential Reporting ("Whistleblowing") Policy was adopted to be
incorporated in the constitution. Minutes: The report
was presented by Councillor Llio Elenid Owen, Cabinet Member for Corporate
Services and Legal. It was
expressed back in January that the Cabinet had adopted a revised Whistleblowing
Policy for Cyngor Gwynedd staff which represented an important step in
strengthening the Council's arrangements in response to the Our Bravery Brought
Justice report. It was explained that there was a call for a policy that would
allow elected and co-opted members to have a pathway to bring concerns about
serious misconduct to light. It was
explained that there was a need to prepare a Policy that would be suitable and
appropriate for elected members, as staff procedure relating to employment
legislation had legal protection within the Public Interest Disclosure Act
1998. It was noted that this policy offered guidance and a clear pathway for
members on how to raise concerns in a safe space, and coexisted with other
arrangements for specific types of concerns such as the Code of Conduct. It was
reiterated that what was being presented was a system where members could bring
issues to light, obtain guidance and feedback on the response steps. The steps
involved in the formulation of the Policy were highlighted which included input
from the Member Enquiries Task Group as well as engagement with all Members.
Consultations with the Standards Committee, the Education and Economy Committee
along with the Protect organisation - a charitable body specialising in
whistleblowing matters - were highlighted. It was emphasised that amendments
submitted by the Scrutiny Committee had been incorporated into the Policy. Members were given the opportunity to ask questions and make
observations. Support for
the policy was noted and the Cabinet Member and the officers were thanked for
their work. It was expressed that it gave members an element of protection and
demonstrated a commitment to a culture of honesty and accountability along with
confidence that concerns are handled appropriately and confidentially. It was
asked how members would know when this policy should be used rather than other
procedures. The response noted by stating that the essence of the policy was to
report any concern and that the Monitoring Officer would identify the pathway
upon receipt. It was
asked how the policy struck a balance between protecting those who raise the
concern and preventing the process from being used in political disputes. It
was expressed that there was a serious purpose to this policy and that there
was an expectation for it to be used for serious conduct, as officers were not
allowed to engage in political matters. It was RESOLVED to adopt a Members'
Confidential Reporting Policy (Whistleblowing) to be included in the
constitution. |
|
|
AMENDMENTS TO THE CONSTITUTION - SECTION 22 - STAFF WHISTLEBLOWING POLICY To submit the report of the Monitoring Officer. Additional documents: Decision: To
accept the information regarding the amendments to Section 22 of the
Constitution. Minutes: The
Monitoring Officer's report was presented stating that it was an organisational
report. It was clarified in April that there had been a change in Employment
Legislation where the categories of unacceptable behaviour had been extended to
include sexual harassment within the definition of protected disclosures. It
was clarified that the Monitoring Officer had the right to amend the
Constitution accordingly, as a result it was noted that it was a formal report
to note the change. Members were given the opportunity to ask questions and make
observations. It was asked whether the word "whistleblowing" could be changed
in English, as it was an unhealthy way of raising concerns. It was explained
that it was a recognised term that was used consistently across all sectors. It was RESOLVED to adopt a Members'
Confidential Reporting Policy (Whistleblowing) to be incorporated in the
constitution. |
|
|
PROCUREMENT THRESHOLDS AND MODIFICATIONS TO THE CONTRACTS PROCEDURE RULES To submit
the report of the Cabinet Member
for Corporate and Legal
Services and the Welsh Language Additional documents:
Decision: 1. To
increase the procurement thresholds as follows: ·
Procurements up to £10,000 single quotation ·
Procurements between £10,000 and £100,000
request three quotations ·
Procurements of over £100,000 open request for
quotations or tenders 2. Make the
minor amendments to
the Council's Contract Procedure Rules as set out in Minutes: The report was presented by Councillor Llio Elenid Owen, Cabinet Member
for Corporate Services and Legal. It was
noted that it was timely to review the Council's tender thresholds and
procurement quotations following a significant change in contracting and
procurement legislation as well as a change to the Council's internal Contracts
Procedure Rules following this Council's decision in March of last year. It was
explained that the current thresholds had been in place since 1996, and that
inflation and prices had risen dramatically over the years. It was
highlighted that further changes had been introduced to ensure that the Council
complied with the Act as well as fine tuning internal arrangements and
providing clarity of the appropriate arrangements. It was noted that the
recommendation was to double the thresholds. It was explained that in setting
the thresholds there was a need to weigh and measure the provision of open
opportunities, encourage competition and the participation of local businesses.
It was emphasised that today's recommendation supported keeping the benefit
local, as higher thresholds were an opportunity to support local businesses by
providing flexibility in the procedures to invite local companies to submit
quotations. It was
expressed that the report had received support from the Governance and Audit
Committee and was being recommended to the Full Council. Members were given the opportunity to ask questions and make
observations. It was expressed that there was no issue with increasing the thresholds
as it provided a better capacity to fund projects by local companies, but it
was pointed out that Anglesey Council's thresholds were much higher. A question
was asked about the proportion of Welsh meat and vegetables bought by the
Council to which it was replied that the response would be provided by the
Education Department. It was
asked what consideration had been given to using a higher threshold to keep the
work local and to what extent small pieces of work for the same company can be
carried out. The response given was that it was a balance of having a practical
system in terms of values, and on the other hand ensuring propriety under
regulations. RESOLVED
1.
To increase the procurement thresholds as follows: ·
Procurements up to £10,000 single quotation ·
Procurements between £10,000 and £100,000 request three quotations ·
Procurements of over £100,000 open request for quotations or
tenders 2.
Make minor amendments to the Council's Contract Procedure Rules as set
out in Appendix 1. |
|
|
NOTICES OF MOTION NOTICE OF MOTION BY COUNCILLOR HUW ROWLANDS In accordance with the Notice of Motion received under Section 4.19 of the Constitution, Councillor Huw Rowlands will propose as follows:- Cyngor
Gwynedd is asked to contact the Welsh Government in order to:- 1.
Express concern that Betsi Cadwaladr University Health Board has been in
special measures for 11 years. 2.
Ask what steps and what efforts that the Welsh Government will take to
improve the health provision in North Wales for the people of Gwynedd. Additional documents: Decision: Cyngor Gwynedd is asked to contact the Welsh Government in order to:-
Minutes: The notice of motion was presented by Councillor Huw Rowlands under
Section 4.19 of the Constitution and was seconded. The member set out the context of the motion,
noting:- ·
That
it stemmed from the frustration at the Board’s failures over a number of years. ·
Special
measures for over 11 years and that not a single state establishment in the
entire history of the Health Board had been in special measures for so
long. ·
It
was highlighted that the Audit had drawn attention last week that the Board had
not made it clear how an investment worth £461 million had been spent or its
impact as a result of a lack of reliable evidence. ·
It
was emphasised that this showed that throwing more money was not successful. ·
It
was noted that all efforts to improve had failed. ·
Looking
at Ysbyty Gwynedd - that the shortcomings were clear without entering buildings
with no parking spaces, full bins and that this kind of neglect for this amount
of money was a greater negligence. ·
Pride
was expressed to see that the Welsh Government had given the Board one last
chance this week. Members expressed enthusiastic support for the
proposal, noting: ·
Confidence in the Welsh Government seeing the
importance of moving forward on the matter. ·
Attention
was drawn to the 16 empty beds in Tywyn. ·
It
was stressed that everyone was aware of the nightmare stories and that the
Government had left it too long to do something about the matter. ·
Frontline
staff were thanked for all their work and for doing a fantastic job in such a
difficult situation and that this was a structural problem. It was RESOLVED to adopt
the motion, namely:- Cyngor Gwynedd is asked to contact the Welsh
Government to: 1. Express concern that Betsi Cadwaladr University Health Board has been in
special measures for 11 years. 2. Ask what steps and what efforts the Welsh Government would be taking to
improve the health provision in North Wales for the people of Gwynedd. |