Venue: Siambr Hywel Dda, Swyddfeydd y Cyngor Caernarfon ac yn rhithiol drwy Zoom. View directions
Contact: Rhodri Jones 01286 679556
| No. | Item |
|---|---|
|
APOLOGIES To receive
any apologies for absence. Additional documents: Minutes: An apology
was received from Councillor Dafydd Davies. |
|
|
DECLARATION OF PERSONAL INTEREST To receive any declaration of personal interest. Additional documents: Minutes: No
declarations of personal interest were received. |
|
|
URGENT ITEMS To note any
items that are a matter of urgency in the view of the Chairman for
consideration. Additional documents: Minutes: None to
note. |
|
|
The
Chairman shall propose that the minutes of the meeting of this Committee, held
on 11 June 2026 be signed as a true record.
Additional documents: Minutes: The Chair signed the minutes of the previous meeting of this committee
held on 11 June 2026, as a true record. |
|
|
CLIMATE AND NATURE EMERGENCY PLAN ANNUAL REPORT 2025/26 To
scrutinise the Climate and Nature Emergency Plan Annual Report 2025/26. Additional documents: Decision: 1.
To
accept the report, noting the observations made during the discussion. 2.
To
welcome the intention to discuss with Welsh Government Ministers the
methodology of calculating carbon emissions in the area of Procurement, along
with a successor to the EC04 scheme which is ending. Minutes: The report was
presented by the Climate Change Programme Manager stating that it reported on
work undertaken in 2025/26 and under the original Climate and Nature Emergency
plan, which had now been updated and adopted by the Cabinet in summer 2026. It was expressed
that the Council had been reporting on Carbon emissions to the Welsh Government
for four years now. It was explained that this provided a firm foundation to
see whether progress was going in the right direction. It was also noted that figures
were presented 'including procurement' and 'excluding procurement' measures, as
the methodology was not entirely accurate with procurement as it was
expenditure-based. It was explained that both pictures showed that they were on
the right track. It was detailed that carbon emissions were falling and carbon
absorption levels had remained unchanged because they had used 2024/25
statistics, but the gap was closing. It was added that there were explanations for
this in the report, but they included a work investment on reducing emissions
from buildings' energy use, the installation of fleet charging points and that
the waste strategy was now operational. It was emphasised that the picture was
broad and complex but that they were on the right track. During the discussion, the following observations were
made: Members thanked the officer for the
report and attention was drawn to calculating carbon emissions from the
procurement system, noting that if it was solely expenditure-based then how
could net zero be reached. With rising costs, it would not be achievable as it
was a constantly moving target. It was added that with increased fuel costs,
emissions would rise through this measure. It was noted that it was absurd to
count carbon footprint through procurement as no one could reach net zero. He
stressed that he was aware that this was a Welsh Government measure but it did
not reflect the situation and that it really needed to be questioned. The
response was that they fully agreed with the observations but that the Council
had taken one positive step by looking at procurement processes. It was
explained that a lot of time had been spent supporting suppliers and helping
them to develop their own carbon management plans. In doing so, it was
explained that it had led to a reduction in carbon levels within the companies
and enabled them to provide accurate carbon data which was fed back to the
Welsh Government. They elaborated by noting that a higher percentage of the
data was accurate as a result of the support provided, but if we wanted to see
this type of project across Wales then much more resources would be needed. It
was added that the Cabinet Member had asked the new Government for a further
discussion on this measure. Attention was drawn to the Carbon Absorption chart by the Council's land assets, and it was asked why there had been a large reduction in the first two years of the plan followed by a gradual increase, with ... view the full minutes text for item 5. |
|
|
HIGHWAY MAINTENANCE - INSTALLATION OF ROAD MARKINGS To review
current arrangements. Additional documents: Decision: 1.
To
accept the report, noting the observations made during the discussion. 2.
To
declare support for developing a business plan for investment to enable the
service to undertake a high percentage of road-marking work internally. 3.
To
recommend to the Highways, Engineering and YGC Department that a performance
measure should be developed with regard to
prioritising road marking and the safety of all road users, including
pedestrians and cyclists. Minutes: The report was
presented, stating that the department was currently looking at steps to
improve the service. The current working arrangements were noted which involved
an external contractor carrying out road marking works, except for a single
manual road marking machine in the south of the county. It was emphasised that
there were only two contractors working across North Wales, so the waiting time
to get the works done could be long. Attention was drawn to the steps to improve
the service, as set out in the report. It was noted that step two was to invest
in an additional manual road marking machine, along with training staff to use
it, for use in the north of the county. It was explained
that step 3 involved developing a business plan to invest in a bespoke road
marking vehicle, submitting an invest-to-save bid. It was added that this would
ensure that works were done faster and that there would be an opportunity to offer
work to neighbouring counties and generate income. It was added that operating
it internally would make it much easier to manage the situation. During the
discussion, the following observations were made: It was noted that the fact that there were
only two contractors available to carry out the work, highlighted the need to
support this case. However, it was expressed that it would be useful to see the
financial case for that as well, perhaps when presenting to the Cabinet to see
the picture over 5-10 years in terms of staffing and maintenance costs along
with the additional income. The response given was that these figures were
essential to submit the bid, but this stage had not been reached yet. It was
noted that the cost would be around £200k investment-wise to purchase the
machine. It was explained that initial talks had begun with the Trunk Roads
Agency, which had noted support and work if going down the investment avenue.
It was elaborated that there had been an initial discussion with nearby
counties. It was expressed that it was not only the financial element that was
crucial but also the Council's reputation, of providing a timely and rapid
response. It was noted that an investment had been made for step 2, which was a
step in the right direction. It was asked how the success of the
service could be defined, as road markings were important for traffic and
safety whilst also being necessary for pedestrians and cyclists. It was asked
how the system considered different users when prioritising road markings, and
how performance measures allowed us to see the scale and location of works, and
what needs were being met. The response given was that prioritisation came down
to risk assessment and that road safety was part of the road inspector's job,
taking into account the entire road including the road markings. It was
explained that measures came into the performance challenge system and that
examples would be considered when reporting. Attention was drawn to road ... view the full minutes text for item 6. |
|
|
EMERGENCY ROAD CLOSURES Ensure that
appropriate arrangements are in place for the management and co-ordination of
road closures in urgent and emergency circumstances. Additional documents: Decision: 1.
To
accept the report, noting the observations made during the discussion. 2.
To
ask the Environment Department to share data including the number of road
closures in urgent or emergency circumstances, the distribution across areas,
and works that take longer than expected. Minutes: The report was
presented, stating that emergency road closures were one part of the work of
the Street Works unit on county roads. It was expressed that in accordance with
the legislation, they were responsible for enabling statutory undertakers to
carry out works on the roads. It was added that there were different processes
to follow when emergency works arose compared to scheduled works. It was noted
that, in an emergency, engagement was not possible as they could not predict where
and when they would happen across such a wide county network. It was explained
that the unit coordinated work in the area, but aimed to minimise disruption to
communities while bearing in mind the need for urgent or emergency works to be
carried out by statutory contractors. It was expressed that, in an age of
communication, it was easy to get information out in an emergency which could
be helpful but also work against them when a high amount of information was
shared or if the time period was short which could create confusion that was
difficult to retract. During the
discussion, the following observations were made: Specific issues with road closures in one
area were highlighted, citing a lack of communication between the Council and
those carrying out the work. It was explained that the Councillor had contacted
the Council on many occasions to note that the road was closed as the Council
was not aware of the work, particularly by Dŵr Cymru/Welsh Water. It was
asked if better cooperation with the road closure companies was possible. It
was explained that Dŵr Cymru had commissioned a company from Cheshire to
close roads, but the works had not taken place and the residents had consequently
reopened the road themselves. It was added that the road had been closed
following this unbeknownst to anyone, therefore this had led to public
transport problems. The response given was that they fully
sympathised with and understood the frustration and that they aimed to have a
healthy relationship with the statutory contractors and that it was expected of
them to share information. While he did not have specific details about the
case in question, it was expressed that cases could change following an
inspection and seeing the extent of the work. It was noted that the system was
not perfect but that they were keen to work together to improve it. It was
stressed that it was essential to receive examples, and that they had regular
meetings with the undertakers to see improvement. It was noted that Dŵr
Cymru had experienced difficulties following appointing a new traffic
management company but they had now seen an improvement. It was added that they
fined if a road was closed without warning. When asked about traffic arrangements, it was asked who sent the maps for traffic diversions. It was noted that these were very useful to share with residents. An example of a diversion following a road closure by Dŵr Cymru was highlighted ... view the full minutes text for item 7. |
|
|
COMMUNITIES SCRUTINY COMMITTEE FORWARD PROGRAMME 2026/27 To present
the Committee’s draft work programme for 2026/27 for adoption. Additional documents: Decision: To adopt
the work programme for 2026/27. Minutes: The report
was presented by the Scrutiny Advisor. She
explained that the Committee's annual workshop had been held on 19 May, where
possible items for scrutiny during 2026/27 had been considered. In the
workshop, items had been prioritised bearing in mind the purpose of scrutiny in
Gwynedd, namely "To contribute to driving improvement in services for the
people of Gwynedd". It was
explained that, following the workshop, some matters had been raised and it was
decided that they would be given consideration. It was decided to move some
items on the draft work programme and to note "Bereavement Service"
as a reserve item. It was emphasised that the forward programme was a working
programme which was constantly under review to ensure that the right matters
were being addressed. During the
discussion, the following observations were made: It was
suggested that a report should be received on the pilot of using hessian bags
for recycling in some areas. It was explained that this update would be seen
and raised when discussing the Environment Department's Performance Challenge
report. It was
expressed that roadside vegetation was a constant problem on rural roads. It
was noted that it was an issue to be discussed in performance scrutiny and to
possibly keep in mind for future scrutiny. RESOLVED To adopt
the work programme for 2026/27. |
|
|
PERFORMANCE CHALLENGE MEETINGS To nominate
representatives to attend performance challenge meetings. Additional documents: Decision: To nominate
the following members to represent the committee in the Environment
Department's performance challenge meetings: ·
Councillors
Stephen Churchman and Arwyn Herald Roberts (with Councillor Beca Roberts in
reserve) Minutes: The report
was presented by the Scrutiny Advisor. It was
expressed following a discussion in the Scrutiny Forum and a call by members of
the scrutiny committee, that there was an intention to pilot inviting two
representatives from each scrutiny committee to attend the internal performance
challenge meetings of one department. It was explained that the Scrutiny Forum
had recommended for a representative from this committee to attend the
Environment Department's performance challenge meeting. Those nominated to
attend were asked to keep in mind that there was a form to complete after the
meeting to be able to report back to the committee. Councillors
Stephen Churchman and Arwyn Herald Roberts were nominated and seconded to
represent the Committee, with Councillor Beca Roberts in reserve should the
need arise. RESOLVED
To
nominate the following members to represent the committee in the Environment
Department's performance challenge meetings: ·
Councillors Stephen Churchman and Arwyn Herald Roberts (with Councillor
Beca Roberts in reserve) |